Safer Sprouts



Fresh and colorful alfalfa sprouts, crisp and crunchy mung bean sprouts, or any of the half dozen other kinds of raw sprouts sold in America today add taste and texture to salads, sandwiches, soups, omelets, and other dishes. What’s more, sprouts can give you plenty of protein, a lot of fiber, and a generous amount of antioxidants like vitamin C.

But those same sprouts-if not grown and processed under hygienic conditions-can also leave you with a nasty case of food poisoning caused by pathogenic microbes such as Salmonella or E. coli O157:H7.

Now, investigations by Agricultural Research Service microbiologist Amy O. Charkowski may help make sprouts safer. She is with the Food Safety and Health Research Unit at Albany, California.

Solutions for Small Farms

In the United States, the delicious, sprouted seeds of red clover, broccoli, wheat, radish, soybean, mung bean, alfalfa, and other vegetables or grains “are produced primarily by small operations,” says Charkowski. Many are family-run. These ‘sprouters,’ as they are nicknamed in the industry, may not be able to afford expensive techniques to kill foodborne pathogens.

“Also,” notes Charkowski, “many sprouters run organic operations.” That means they simply won’t use irradiation or another option-bathing sprouts in a chlorine-containing chemical called calcium hypochlorite. This compound-the same white powder that’s used to disinfect swimming pools-is recommended by the Food and Drug Administration for sanitizing sprouts.

The FDA currently advises all consumers to cook sprouts before eating them. And it recommends that the young, the elderly, and those with compromised immune systems should not eat sprouts.

Salmonella and E. coli can flourish in the warm, moist indoor environment in which seeds are forced to sprout. Typically, unsprouted seeds are placed on trays or in rotating drums. There, they are kept warm and are periodically moistened with a fine mist of clean water.

There are many opportunities for the seeds to become contaminated with the microbes before they’re even purchased by sprouters. Salmonellaor E. coli could be harbored in bird droppings, in manure applied to fields as fertilizer, in contaminated water that’s used to irrigate fields, or perhaps in dirt left over in improperly cleaned seed-sorting machinery. The pathogens might also live in droppings of rodents that eat seeds stored in bags, bins, or silos.

Microbes’ Preferred Attack Sites

Charkowski’s studies with sprouted seeds of radish, alfalfa, broccoli, and mung bean may yield tactics that sprouters can use to ensure their products are free of Salmonella and E. coli. Experiments in her laboratory at the ARS Western Regional Research Center have revealed that these pathogens prefer to attack the roots and-secondarily-the seedcoats. Her studies, which required tracking the microbes’ progress in thousands of sprouts, are among the first few to reveal the pathogens’ priorities.

Related tests may indicate what sprout-produced compounds-such as amino acids-inadvertently nurture the attacking microbes. In addition, the experiments should show whether harmless bacteria could be applied to the sprouts to deprive the pathogens of the vital compounds.

“We might be able to undermine the harmful pathogens,” says Charkowski, “if we can use beneficial bacteria to outcompete them in the race for essential compounds.”

Salmonella Genes Scrutinized

In other approaches, Charkowski is probing the genetic makeup of Salmonella. Her intent: To discover which genes Salmonella “expresses”-that is, activates-when it contaminates sprouts.

For one group of experiments, she’s producing genetically engineered lab strains of Salmonella by randomly knocking out genes. Then, she’s determining whether removing those genes will reduce the microbe’s ability to infect sprouts.

In a second set of genetic engineering investigations, Charkowski and postdoctoral fellow Jeri D. Barak will track the genes that Salmonellaexpresses as it colonizes the sprouts. They will do that with Salmonella that contain a gene borrowed from a jellyfish. The jellyfish gene causes Salmonella to fluoresce a bright green whenever a Salmonella gene turns on.

In a competition among ARS labs nationwide, Charkowski won special ARS funding that allows Barak to join in this genetic research effort.

Less Effective Salmonella Found

“So far,” Charkowski reports, “one of our most interesting strains of genetically modified Salmonella is only about one-tenth as effective in colonizing sprouts as conventional Salmonella.” But which of Salmonella’s 4,000 to 5,000 genes are missing or disabled in that strain? Help in identifying those genes-and their makeup, or sequence-may come from biotechnologists who are part of an international venture to sequence Salmonella genes.

In the meantime, Charkowski’s quest to find out which Salmonella genes are crucial to successful attacks on sprouts is likely unique. “Once we know which Salmonella genes are critical in an invasion,” she says, “we may be able to develop a strategy to activate and amplify the natural protective response by the sprouts.”

“The genes that Salmonella activates when it invades sprouts,” says Charkowski, “are likely the same as those it uses when it colonizes other fresh produce and perhaps meats and poultry. That means the food safety strategies developed from our genetic studies may help protect these other foods from Salmonella, as well.”-By Marcia Wood, Agricultural Research Service Information Staff.

This research is part of Food Safety, an ARS National Program (#108) 

Amy O. Charkowski is in the USDA-ARS Food Safety and Health Research Unit, Western Regional Research Center, 800 Buchanan St., Albany, CA 94710; phone (510) 559-5647, fax (510) 559-5948.

 “Safer Sprouts” was published in the August 2000 issue of Agricultural Research magazine.